Get in Touch Menu

Navigating the age of ‘Taylor’-made working practices

18 August 2017

The modern workplace is increasingly characterised by flexible, ad hoc working as more people become self-employed or work under zero hours contracts.

A flexible workforce can benefit businesses that have peaks and troughs in demand and workload, and, despite fears of exploitation, there can be benefits for workers who have other commitments and priorities around which they have to fit their work.

That said, the emergence of the gig economy and other platform-based working has illustrated that exploitation occurs, as reports of individuals earning as little as £2.50 an hour have clearly demonstrated. Recent high-profile tribunal cases, such as Uber and Pimlico Plumbers, have also highlighted that such arrangements present problems when determining employment status and tax liability.

In response to this, at the end of 2016, the Government launched a review of the UK labour market. Published this summer, the Taylor Review of Modern Working Practices considered the implications of these new forms of work and paid particular attention to the gig economy. It looked not only at how people are engaged in work, but also the quality of the work arrangement, identified the need to adapt the current legal framework to reflect emerging business models, and noted that a distinction between employee and self-employed is not enough.

The review endorsed the present system of employment status which distinguishes between employee, worker and self-employed, and recommended that these categories are also used for tax purposes. Further suggestions in the report include the category of ‘worker’ (currently used to categorise individuals in less formal employment relationships) being renamed ‘dependent contractor’, and the suggestion that those in this group receive at least basic employment rights, alongside a statement of employment on commencement of work.

Despite the report noting that ‘too many’ employers rely on zero hours contracts, short-hours or agency contracts, it did not go so far as to recommend banning, or heavily regulating the use of them. However, it did recommend that a higher rate of national minimum wage should be considered for hours not guaranteed by the individual’s contract, and  the introduction of a right to request a ‘guaranteed hours contract’ when an individual has been under a zero hours contract for 12 months.

It remains to be seen whether the government will implement the review’s recommendations. In the meantime it makes it difficult for employers to know where their obligations lie when engaging individuals under these atypical working arrangements.

Matthew Clayton leads our employment law team. Legal directory Chambers says clients appreciate his down-to-earth, practical and common- sense approach”. To guide employers on how to navigate the maze of flexible working and stay on the right side of the law, Matthew and the employment law team are hosting a half-day ‘Building flexibility into your workforce’ seminar at Stonehouse Court Hotel on 21 September (£30 inc. VAT and lunch). Click here for more details and how to book.

We're here to help
Disclaimer: All legal information is correct at the time of publication but please be aware that laws may change over time. This article contains general legal information but should not be relied upon as legal advice. Please seek professional legal advice about your specific situation - contact us; we’d be delighted to help.
Matthew Clayton MA LLM (Cantab), CIPP/E
View profile
Mathew Clayton
Related services
Share this article
Resources to help

Related articles

In depth: The King’s speech & employment law – what you need to know

Employment & business immigration

The newly-elected Labour government has set out its ambitious plans for employment law reform in the Employment Rights Bill, representing “the biggest upgrade to workers’ rights in a generation.” The…

Hifsa O'Kelly LLB (Hons)
Associate, solicitor

General election 2024: what to expect in business immigration

Employment & business immigration

With polling day well underway, candidates from all parties – like the public – await the results of the 2024 general election. We have summarised the pledges of Labour, the…

Klára Grmelová MGR (LLM Czech)

Webinar: Business immigration for employers June 2024

Employment & business immigration

In this free webinar our experienced employment and business immigration lawyers guide you through the critical points to consider when employing non-UK workers. Along with plenty of useful hints and…

Contact us