Back
We continue to provide our legal services through the COVID-19 pandemic. Please visit our COVID-19 Hub for legal insights, or contact us directly.
Get in Touch Menu

Legal ‘discretion’ may help defaulting buyers reclaim deposit

27 June 2008

In a difficult market it is inevitable that more land sales will fall through, some even after contracts have been exchanged and deposits paid.

It is a standard requirement in land transactions that a buyer pays a deposit on exchange of contracts. He gets the deposit back if the seller fails to complete, but forfeits it if he is the one to drop out.

That is, at least, the expectation in standard practice but in fact the court has discretion to order the deposit to be returned if it thinks fit. This little-know discretion (contained in the Law of Property Act 1925) is an attractive idea for defaulting buyers, particularly if the deposit is substantial. But as recent case law shows, there must be very persuasive reasons as to why the deposit should not be forfeited.

The starting point for the court is that repayment should only be ordered if it is the fairest course in all the circumstances. The consequences of paying a deposit should be certain, and buyers should expect to forfeit if they fail to complete. They should not be able to reclaim the deposit merely because the sale does not go through.

The court will look at how close the buyer came to performing the contract, what other choices he is able to offer the seller and how they would compare with the actual performance of the original contract terms. If the seller can re-sell at a higher price, the return of the deposit might be justified, but in itself this is not a sufficient ground. Equally, the conduct of the respective parties may be considered. This does not necessarily prevent the seller, however, from playing hard ball and refusing to negotiate with the buyer outside the terms of the original contract.

Buyers should make sure they definitely want (and can) go ahead with the transaction before exchanging contracts and paying the deposit.

As always, if you need commercial and pragmatic legal advice, we’re here to help so please get in touch.

Contact us

 

Contact
Alasdair Garbutt LLB (Hons)
Partner
View profile
Alasdair Garbutt
Related services
Share this article
Resources to help

Related articles

Commercial landlords & tenants: What are your options?

Commercial property

Commercial property solicitor Emma Thompson answers some key pandemic-related questions for landlords and tenants in the commercial sphere. I am a tenant, do I have to pay my rent? If…

Emma Thompson LLB (Hons)
Solicitor

Planning use classes overhaul: COVID-19 sparks major change

Commercial property

From 1 September 2020, the categories under the Town and Country Planning (Use Classes Order) 1987 are changing to create two new use classes. It is hoped that the overhaul…

Charlotte Brunsdon LLB, BA (Hons)
Solicitor

COVID-19: a commercial property update for landlords & tenants

Commercial property

As you will be aware from some of our previous updates, a number of measures have been put in place to give businesses the breathing space and tools they need…

Emma Thompson LLB (Hons)
Solicitor
Contact us