Back
We continue to provide our legal services through the COVID-19 lockdown. Please visit our COVID-19 Hub for legal insights, or contact us directly.
Get in Touch Menu

Landlords - beware of the risk of releasing guarantors

04 June 2014

It is well-established law that a landlord risks releasing a tenant’s guarantor from its obligations under a lease if the terms of that lease are varied without consultation with, or the consent of, the guarantor.

This has been illustrated once more by the Court of Appeal in the recent case of Topland v Smiths News Trading.

The tenant went into administration and the landlord called on the parent company, which had guaranteed the lease, to comply with obligations under the guarantee. The guarantor pointed to an earlier licence for alterations which allowed the tenant to construct a new garden centre on part of the site. The guarantor claimed that the effect of the document was to increase its obligations under the lease and that, as it had not been a party to the licence, it was released from any further liabilities under the guarantee. The landlord argued that the amount of rent payable had not been increased and that the guarantor’s liabilities were no more onerous than before.

However, the court ruled that the guarantor was entitled to expect that if the lease was to be varied (whether by means of a licence for alterations or otherwise) then its consent should first be sought, as clearly the document had the potential of adding to the obligations of both the tenant and the guarantor. As a result, the issue of the licence for alterations did release the guarantor from all liability under its guarantee.

Therefore the message for landlords is that they should always consult the guarantor of a lease before agreeing any variation of the terms of a lease with the tenant, or risk the guarantor avoiding all liability. Any landlord would be well advised to seek advice from their solicitor.

For advice, or more information, please contact alasdair.garbutt@willans.co.uk or call 01242 514000.

We're here to help

To read other legal news visit www.willans.co.uk/news or contact lesley.kadwell@willans.co.uk to receive our quarterly legal email bulletin Law News.

Contact
Alasdair Garbutt LLB (Hons)
Partner
View profile
Alasdair Garbutt
Related services
Share this article
Resources to help

Related articles

An e-sign of the times?

Commercial property

Times are changing but there’s still a place for pen and ink when it comes to legal property documents, explains paralegal Yasmin Lewis. In the commercial property sector there is…

Yasmin Lewis LLB (Hons)
Paralegal

Trustees' duties & charity land: 6 frequently-asked questions

Commercial property

Getting the best deal for your charity, while complying with charity law, is part and parcel of being a trustee; but what are the legal requirements when it comes to…

Charlotte Brunsdon LLB, BA (Hons)
Solicitor

Buying a business or property in the hospitality & leisure sector?

Commercial property

Whether you’re a first-time business buyer entering into the leisure sector, or you’re an experienced hotelier embarking on your next acquisition, the importance of doing your legal ‘homework’ shouldn’t be…

Alasdair Garbutt LLB (Hons)
Partner
Contact us