The commercial property market has been keenly awaiting judgment in Prudential Assurance Company Ltd and Luctor Limited and others v PR Powerhouse Ltd.
The concern was that a CVA (company voluntary arrangement) might be used to remove landlords’ rights to guaranteed rental income.
The High Court has now ruled that an attempt by a tenant company to strip away landlord guarantees provided by its parent through the use of a CVA was unfairly prejudicial to the landlords. One of our solicitors briefly examines the case and what it means for landlords.
What is a CVA? A CVA is a compromise or other arrangement with creditors to satisfy a company’s debts. A proposal is put to creditors at a meeting and, if approved, is binding. A CVA can be challenged if it unfairly prejudices the interest of a creditor. If the challenge succeeds, the court may revoke or suspend the CVA.
Powerhouse owned a number of high street electrical stores and superstores, some held under leases where the landlords had the benefit of parent company guarantees.
The company got into financial difficulties, informed creditors that they intended to close 35 stores and proposed a CVA. Broadly speaking, the CVA recommended a capped fund from which creditors of the closed stores would receive just 28p in every pound owed to them. All other creditors were to be unaffected by the CVA.
Not surprisingly, the landlords challenged the validity of the CVA and were successful. When comparing the position of the landlords with their fellow creditors, the court said it was obvious that the landlords were unfairly prejudiced and left in a far worse position.
Had Powerhouse gone into insolvent liquidation, the landlords would have had the benefit of the parent guarantees. All the creditors, other than the scheme fund creditors (which included the landlords) were entitled to be paid in full. Effectively, the claims of the landlords were to be discharged from the fund at a fraction of their worth in order that other creditors could be paid in full. The court felt that this result was illogical as well as unfair.
While the decision clarifies that a CVA may not directly release guarantees, it can have the indirect effect of doing so by obliging a creditor to treat the guarantee as though it had been released.
The concern was that, had the decision gone the other way, there could have been a significant impact on the valuation of leasehold property where parent guarantees were used to support tenants’ covenant strength.
Creditors, and in particular landlords, need to scrutinise the terms of a proposed CVA carefully before accepting it to ensure that the CVA offer is a fair compromise for all creditors, not just one category of creditor.
As always, if you need commercial and pragmatic legal advice, we’re here to help so please get in touch.
In the Chancellor’s first Budget speech last year, made as COVID-19 started to take hold in the UK, Rishi Sunak promised to do “whatever it takes to support the economy”.…
Commercial property solicitor Emma Thompson answers some key pandemic-related questions for landlords and tenants in the commercial sphere. I am a tenant, do I have to pay my rent? If…
From 1 September 2020, the categories under the Town and Country Planning (Use Classes Order) 1987 are changing to create two new use classes. It is hoped that the overhaul…
We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. By clicking “Accept”, you consent to the use of ALL cookies.
This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through our website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorised as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyse and understand how you use our website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies but it may affect your browsing experience on our website. You can find our cookie policy here.
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for our website to function and enable core functionality such as security and accessibility. These cookies do not store any personal information. You can block these cookies by changing your browser settings, but this may affect how the website functions.
We use performance cookies such as Google Analytics to help us count the number of visitors and to see how visitors move around our website when they are using it. This helps us to improve the way our website works, for example, by ensuring that users are finding what they are looking for easily. The cookies collect information in a way that does not directly identify anyone. For more information on how these cookies work, please see our cookie policy.