Back
Get in Touch Menu

Clawing back bonuses – is it legal?

13 March 2012

The issue of bonuses, particularly bankers’ bonuses is still dominating the headlines. In February, it emerged that Lloyds Banking Group planned to strip a number of top executives of about £2 million in bonuses as a penalty for a financial scandal that cost the taxpayer-backed bank £3.2 billion last year.

It is important to stress that this unprecedented attempt to claw back bonus payments is not a universal remedy. In this case, because it is a consequence of the adjustment of the bonus pot caused by the PPI scandal, it is provided for in Lloyd’s contractual arrangement.

Many opinions have been voiced suggesting that bonuses should be cut or withdrawn. However in the real world, whether or not politicians or the general public like it, the status of a bonus is a legal matter – does the contract allow it or not?

If employers want the option of being able to withdraw, or not to pay, a bonus, they must put in place a tightly-drafted contractual definition. Some companies may try to allow for flexibility by describing bonuses as ‘discretionary’ but simply attaching this label is no guarantee that payment is, indeed discretionary. If such a clause goes on to detail how the employee would qualify for a bonus or the employee has always received a bonus, then very often it may not be ‘discretionary’ at all.

A well-drafted contract could save money, embarrassment and the risk of litigation in the event a company wants to say ‘no’ to a bonus on the grounds that it is not warranted.

As always, if you need commercial and pragmatic legal advice, we’re here to help so please get in touch.

Contact us

Disclaimer: All legal information is correct at the time of publication but please be aware that laws may change over time. This article contains general legal information but should not be relied upon as legal advice. Please seek professional legal advice about your specific situation - contact us; we’d be delighted to help.
Contact
Matthew Clayton MA LLM (Cantab), CIPP/E
Partner
Mathew Clayton
View profile
Related services
Share this article
Resources to help

Related articles

Webinar: Autumn 2025 employment law update

Employment & business immigration

In this free webinar, our experienced employment lawyers took you through the latest developments and top talking points in UK employment legislation. As well as a Q&A session at the…

Willans
Solicitors

What are the business benefits of employee training and development?

Employment & business immigration

Our online employee training platform, Willans eLearn, offers organisations the chance to enroll on over 170 training courses to suit their business needs. Here, our employment law and business immigration…

Simon Pathé FCILEx
Partner, chartered legal executive

The significant changes to business immigration that are now in place

Employment & business immigration

The government’s plan to “create an immigration system which promotes growth but is controlled and managed” has led to a number of updates. Here, our team of experts looks into…

Klára Grmelová MGR (LLM Czech)
Solicitor
Contact us