Get in Touch Menu

Copyright infringement claim in ‘Star Wars’ case

16 November 2011

In the recent case of Lucasfilms Limited and others v Ainsworth and another, Mr Ainsworth, who lives in England, had been selling ‘Star Wars’ helmets and armour. Unimpressed, the film company decided to wage war and brought copyright and trade mark infringement proceedings in America.

A US judgment against Ainsworth included an award of $10m for infringement.

But Lucasfilms’ forces proved to be less strong outside the US. The English courts declined to enforce the American judgment. Lucasfilms pushed on with the case. It was referred to the Supreme Court, which upheld the lower English court’s decision. The stormtrooper helmets could not be considered as ‘sculptures’ under English law that protects intellectual property rights (IPR).

The media reporting of the case has tended to reflect the film’s storyline (‘underdog’ defendant overcomes ‘big’ claimant). But from a legal perspective there is a more interesting and significant point.

As the decision shows, the English courts have judicial authority in cases involving US copyright infringement claims because there is no longer legislation preventing this. It is notable that, among other things, the modern trend is in favour of enforcement of foreign IPR. The Court referred to European law, which only assigned exclusive jurisdiction to the country where the IPR originated in certain circumstances, which did not apply in this case.

This could have a considerable implication for future IPR litigation, since it would allow claims for foreign copyright infringement to be dealt with by the English court and when the defendant has a sufficient connection to this jurisdiction, the force may well be with us!

If you need clear and pragmatic legal advice, we’re here to help so please get in touch.

Contact us

Click to download our fact sheets A basic guide to intellectual property rights and Intellectual property disputes

Disclaimer: All legal information is correct at the time of publication but please be aware that laws may change over time. This article contains general legal information but should not be relied upon as legal advice. Please seek professional legal advice about your specific situation - contact us; we’d be delighted to help.
Nick Cox LLB (Hons)
Consultant, solicitor
View profile
Nick Cox
Related services
Share this article
Resources to help

Related articles

Changes to company law – what businesses need to know


This week, initial changes to company law – including the biggest changes to Companies House since it began – will start to take effect. Here, our corporate and commercial team…

Chris Wills LLB (Hons)

Unearthing the implicit duty of cooperation in commercial contracts


In the world of business, contracts are the bedrock upon which deals are built. These carefully crafted documents are a testament to the mutual understanding between parties, outlining their respective…

Richard Holland BA (Hons)
Senior associate, solicitor

Why sole director companies should check articles of association


A recent case has highlighted the importance of ensuring a company is incorporated with carefully drafted articles of association, if there is only one director. All limited companies must have…

Helen Howes LLM
Associate, solicitor
Contact us