Back
Get in Touch Menu

Japanese knotweed found to cause ‘loss of amenity’ for homeowners in landmark ruling

06 July 2018

The Court of Appeal recently ruled on a claim brought by two South Wales’ homeowners against Network Rail because the company had allowed Japanese knotweed to invade their properties.

The company had appealed against an earlier decision that had awarded compensation to the claimant homeowners on the basis that their properties had been devalued by the presence of the knotweed. Mr Recorder Grubb had decided that the efforts made by the company to control the knotweed had been inadequate. As the plant caused a nuisance to the two homeowners, they were entitled to damages to cover the cost of an effective treatment plan, and for loss of value based on how the property values would be affected, even after the treatment plan had been completed.

Sir Terence Etherton, the Master of the Rolls and  the court’s most senior judge, gave judgment and decided that the judge had gone too far by saying that the homeowners were entitled to damages for loss in value in the way the judge had said.

However, he went on to say that because the encroachment on their land by the knotweed was a nuisance, the homeowners didn’t have to show that the properties had been actually damaged. He explained that the presence of the knotweed alone was an interference with their use and enjoyment of the land, and that they were entitled to damages.

In upholding the original decision, but for different reasons, the Master of the Rolls referred to established principles and in doing so gave guidance on how homeowners might approach claims like this in future.

The case has obvious potential repercussions and we must wait to see if it is appealed to the Supreme Court. It begs the question, what is the difference between the diminution of value in a sale price, and the damages for loss of amenity caused by the presence of the knotweed?

The issues raised by this case may, like the knotweed, not go away that easily.

Partner Nick Cox, a practitioner with over 30 years’ experience, is rated by independent legal directory Chambers for his property litigation expertise. He specialises in contentious landlord and tenant work and is an experienced civil and commercial mediator. 

We're here to help
Contact
Nick Cox LLB (Hons)
Partner
View profile
Nick Cox
Related services
Share this article
Resources to help

Related articles

Do I really need to bother with a shareholders’ agreement?...

Corporate

When starting out, many businesses naturally want to keep costs to a minimum. This often results in them regarding a shareholders’ agreement as something optional or something to consider at…

Helen Howes LLM
Trainee solicitor

Protecting your brand on an international scale

Intellectual property & protection

Despite the significant resources which a company will allocate to international brand protection, it is surprising how often trade mark protection programmes are launched without a clear strategy. An international…

Kym Fletcher LLB (Hons) Euro
Consultant, solicitor

Brexit Q&A: How can my business manage post-Brexit risks?

Commercial

The key to navigating Brexit for any business is planning. Right now, despite the uncertainty around what Brexit may or may not look like, all businesses (whether they trade directly…

Chris Wills LLB (Hons)
Partner
Contact us